"We lived together for about a week or two, and then I got back to my home, and then he actually did drop me. He removed me from Find My Friends," Sara says.

While the pair repeatedly expressed their love for each other, they struggled to get on the same page about religion and social issues.

"Also, me saying no to a marriage, why would I continue dating someone? If you're going to say no to that, why even continue the relationship?" Sara Carton tells PEOPLE after Ben Mezzenga suggested th